Why Smart Marketing Still Wins

Maria Alonso is an award-winning marketing strategist and industry disruptor, redefining advertising with bold campaigns and iconic brands.

In the ever-evolving marketing landscape, where attention spans are short and competition is fierce, one element remains timeless: persuasion. From traditional billboards to TikTok ads, the ability to influence a consumer’s decision—ethically and authentically—is what turns messaging into movement.

Having spent over 15 years in multicultural advertising and brand strategy, I’ve seen how the art of persuasion has shifted. Today’s audiences are informed, skeptical and values-driven. They don’t want to be sold to—they want to feel seen, heard and understood. That’s where the true power of persuasive advertising lies.

The Psychology Of Persuasion In Marketing

At its core, persuasive advertising is about influencing behavior through a mix of emotion, logic and trust. Aristotle laid the groundwork with his three pillars of persuasion:

• Ethos (credibility): Does the brand seem trustworthy and knowledgeable?

• Pathos (emotion): Does the ad make me feel something?

• Logos (logic): Does the message make sense and solve a problem I have?

Modern marketers leverage these pillars—often unknowingly—through influencer endorsements (ethos), emotional storytelling (pathos) and benefit-driven messaging (logos). The most successful campaigns balance all three.

Emotional Marketing That Moves People

One of the most persuasive tools in advertising is emotion. People may justify their purchases logically, but most decisions are made emotionally.

In a campaign I led for a nonprofit, we reimagined child sponsorship by allowing children to choose their sponsors. Capturing those moments of children selecting their sponsors on camera created deeply human, emotional content that resonated with donors—and ultimately drove engagement far beyond traditional models.

Why did it work? Because we shifted the power dynamic. We gave donors a chance to feel chosen, rather than the choosers. That reversal created emotional resonance—and that’s where persuasion lives.

From Flashy To Authentic: The New Power Of Trust

In today’s marketplace, trust is currency. According to Edelman’s Trust Barometer, 62% of people say they trust businesses, the highest level of trust compared to other institutions like government or media—but people will only trust businesses if their actions align with their messaging.

This is where many brands get it wrong. Take Pepsi’s infamous Kendall Jenner ad, which attempted to tap into social activism without any prior history of doing so. The backlash was swift because audiences could smell the inauthenticity.

Contrast that with Ben & Jerry’s. Their activism is embedded in their brand DNA—from climate justice to racial equity. Their actions match their words, and that consistency earns loyalty.

In marketing, persuasion without trust is manipulation. And manipulation doesn’t work anymore.

Social Proof, Scarcity And Subtle Cues

In digital marketing, two psychological triggers continue to prove effective: social proof and scarcity.

When consumers see others engaging with a brand—through reviews, user-generated content or influencer partnerships—they’re more likely to trust and follow suit. In a campaign I worked on with a wellness brand, A/B testing showed that ads featuring real customer testimonials outperformed feature-based ads by 30%.

Scarcity, when used ethically, also drives action. Limited-time offers or “only 3 left in stock” messages create urgency. But the key is authenticity—fake scarcity erodes trust and hurts your brand in the long run.

Cultural Relevance As A Persuasive Strategy

Persuasion isn’t one-size-fits-all. For brands serving diverse audiences, cultural relevance is critical.

When I led multicultural strategy for a major telecom company, our early ads missed the mark despite being translated into Spanish. After deeper research, we adjusted the creative to reflect bicultural identity, family values and the nuances of language—and engagement soared.

Persuasive marketing must speak the language of your audience—not just linguistically, but emotionally and culturally. That requires listening, testing and investing in authenticity.

From Product Features To Shared Values

In the past, persuasive ads were all about product features. Then came benefits. Now, it’s about shared values. Consumers want to know what you stand for—and if it aligns with their beliefs.

A great example is Patagonia. Their “Don’t Buy This Jacket” ad wasn’t just reverse psychology. It was a bold value statement on sustainability. The result? Increased brand loyalty, press coverage and trust.

In my own work, I’ve seen how shifting from transactional messaging to values-driven storytelling changes the game. When people see their identity or aspirations reflected in your brand, persuasion becomes connection.

The Role Of AI In Persuasion

AI has revolutionized marketing—from personalized email journeys to predictive product recommendations. But here’s the truth: AI can optimize persuasion, but it can’t replace it.

AI-driven copy or image testing can tell us what performs best, but it’s the human story, the creative insight and the emotional nuance that drives real connection. Brands that rely solely on algorithms risk sounding robotic, impersonal and disconnected.

The future of persuasion in advertising is human-first, AI-assisted. Let the tech do the heavy lifting, but let real humans guide the message.

Closing Thoughts: Why Persuasion Still Matters

In a world of cluttered feeds and ever-shorter attention spans, persuasion isn’t about shouting louder—it’s about speaking more meaningfully.

The most effective advertising doesn’t just grab attention—it changes minds, stirs emotion and builds relationships over time. It respects the intelligence of the consumer and invites them into something bigger than a transaction.

Persuasion is both art and science—but above all, it’s a reflection of how well we understand people. And that, in marketing, is where the real power lies.

Forbes Communications Council is an invitation-only community for executives in successful public relations, media strategy, creative and advertising agencies. Do I qualify?